Friday, January 19, 2007

The Chicken or the Egg?

A reoccuring theme concerning arts and cultural tourism/economic development keeps surfacing lately, and I wonder if anyone else has thoughts on this. Susan Burack wrote the following in her weekly Keewenaw Arts Column in the Daily Mining Gazette shortly after the December 7, 2006, MCACA conference:

Thursday 14 December 06
"Last Thursday, I had the opportunity to attend "Driving Michigan's Economic Engine: Using Culture and Tourism to Fuel Community Prosperity" in Lansing. This was the annual conference of the Michigan Council for Arts and Cultural Affairs which is in the Department of History, Arts, and Libraries. As Governor Granholm stated in her opening remarks (videotaped), it was
strongly supported by many other departments and agencies. There is a saying about cutting the cloth to fit the fashion and at the state level it seems that is what has happened. Where are the arts? Growing Michigan's economy through cultural tourism. The tourism industry has become one of the main drivers of the state's economic engine as the automotive
>industry tanks.

We have known for a long time that arts and culture are good for the economy. People who attend arts events and support arts buy gas, stay in motels, eat in restaurants, and shop. That is what is referred to as the "multiplier effect" and is set at anywhere from three to twenty five percent of the cost of the art.

We also know that people prefer to live in a place where there is arts and culture. Places where artists live are good places to live. People who visit places where there is cultural heritage stay longer and spend more money. What happens when arts and culture exist not only to enrich our lives but also become the foundation for community prosperity? Arts, culture, history, and heritage are in danger of getting lost. Marketing Michigan risks focusing on arts as a commodity.

Tom Tikkanen has said of Calumet, a Main Street community, that we have it all. We do indeed have the arts, the culture, the history, and the heritage (as well as the woods, the beaches, and the sunrises and sunsets). But they are real. They are authentic. They grew here and they live here. If people want to come visit, we welcome them. But, what is here is here FIRST for the
people who live here.

What happened to the arts? What happened to the Arts Council's conference? Where were the artists? They were given ten minutes at the beginning of "break out" sessions and they were labeled "Creative Tone Setters." Yikes!

The warning sirens were blaring and the warning lights were flashing. If one listened carefully, the speakers didn't even say the words, arts and culture. It was all about creative economic growth, community development through civic tourism, technologies in tourism, tourism assets, attracting tourists, tourism partners, new audiences, and state resources for tourism.

Instead of resources for how tourism benefits arts and artists, the perspective has shifted to how arts and artists benefit tourism. Something is wrong with this picture! When we focus so much on meeting the needs of the tourism industry, we risk becoming a Mackinac City, a Disneyland. Not
the kind of place most people want to live in. "

It boils down to what is more important to fund: basic functions and programming of arts and culture organizations, or marketing and tourism initiatives, and cultural economic development education projects for communities that benefit all organizations and Michigan as a whole? Can we do both in these tough economic times? If arts organizations dissappear, what will be marketed and why will people stay in communities?

Perhaps I am seeing a conflict where one shouldn't exist. after all, cultural economic development is about seeing the assets a community already has as being economically valuable and not just for more warm and fuzzy reasons, such as entertainment, education or a meaningful and rich quality of life.

Comparisons can be made to the environmental movement. There are a certain number of people who will not be concerned about protecting nature unless there is an economic gain--when gas prices soar, SUV sales drop. Environmentalists are finally realizing this and gathering data and arguments to convince this sector that it is in their best interest to support their cause. Others know the intrinsic spiritual, helath and happiness benefits that come from a walk in the woods or observing the patterns of snowflakes. Ideally everyone will understand all the benefits of nature--and the arts--and we can work together to strengthen and protect them.

No comments: